Locus Map - forum

Development => Discussion/New features => Topic started by: 0709 on October 16, 2021, 11:54:57

Title: Improve the Locus gpx (rte) route export.
Post by: 0709 on October 16, 2021, 11:54:57
The Locus gpx (rte)route export.

Can it be offered in a more valuable way ?
Optimise by exporting as standard compact route.
Contains only start & shaping & Via and Finish as route points.

Picture. Locus navtrack. The coloured sections exported as the routepoints.

gpx file in the attachment. (Track + route)

Video: https://youtu.be/blarVfTsFIo

Notice the fast Mapsource route calculation.
Compare with the reference track overlay.
Title: Re: Improve the Locus gpx (rte) route export.
Post by: Andrew Heard on October 17, 2021, 00:02:11
>Who actually uses the current Locus gpx export?
I only use non-RTE format, so happy for you to ignore or discard my thoughts below

>Contains only start & shaping & Via and Finish as route points.
but dangerous - without any knowledge of the routing profile, on import the viewer (most likely Locus) could (mostly likely) create a subtly or completely different (unwanted) route/ track. Any setting like this should not be the default.

I know this because my old Garmin eTrex would generate completely different (unwanted) route/ track when only start/ finish point was in the GPX file (exported from RWGPS). As a new GPS user it was very confusing.

So there needs to be a clear warning on the danger of this style of export. Maybe the addition of a (?) icon/ button alongside the checkbox to explain the ramifications.
Title: Re: Improve the Locus gpx (rte) route export.
Post by: Menion on October 18, 2021, 08:58:34
Hello Willy, Andrew,

GPX RTE export was made a long time ago with a single purpose in mind: support for older Garmin devices that were unable to read TKR GPX routes. I do not measure how much this feature is still used to be true, but it works well as is. I simply think there is no need for improvements. Only what I may think about, is to completely remove this option.

I miss in both posts the main info for me: why this change? What should be the benefit? Are you using in any Garmin devices this GPX RTE format?
Title: Re: Improve the Locus gpx (rte) route export.
Post by: Andrew Heard on October 18, 2021, 09:46:36
I don't suggest any changes @menion. I was purely debating pros &  cons of the original post & my experience (pitfalls for young players) from years ago with an old Garmin eTrex before moving to smart(er) devices.
Title: Re: Improve the Locus gpx (rte) route export.
Post by: Menion on October 21, 2021, 11:32:45
Oki, understand. I'll measure how many users use this feature and consider its complete removal. Thanks.
Title: Re: Improve the Locus gpx (rte) route export.
Post by: arnor on October 21, 2021, 19:38:22
I like the proposal of 0709:

'Can it be offered in a more valuable way ?
Optimise by exporting as standard compact route.
Contains only start & shaping & Via and Finish as route points.'